NEWBERG, Ore. — At the Nov. 9 work session, the Newberg-Dundee School Board spent three hours discussing five school-closure models before directing the Newberg-Dundee School District to analyze three of them for a recommendation at the board’s Nov. 17 meeting.

At the end of the meeting, the board advanced Models C, D, and H for the district to analyze. Models D and H both propose closing Ewing Young Elementary and Joan Austin Elementary. The difference is that Model H would convert the district to K-4, 5-6, and 7-8 grade cohorts, with fifth and sixth graders attending what is currently Chehalem Valley Middle School and seventh and eighth graders attending Mountain View Middle School.

Community-supported journalism

This article was made possible by the generous support of Newsberg readers and advertisers. Independent local news takes real resources to produce. If Newsberg is valuable to you, please consider joining us — for as little as $1 a month, or with a one-time gift in any amount.

Tax-deductible giving options available. Newsberg is community-owned, independent, and free to read.

Model C proposes closing both Ewing Young and Antonia Crater Elementary. Model G, which did not advance, proposes closing Ewing Young and Mountain View Middle School and turning Crater into a sixth-grade center because it shares a campus with Chehalem Valley Middle School.

The NDSD will analyze the three models using feedback from the work session and comments from staff members and parents, and will present its recommended model at the Nov. 17 meeting. The board will then consider a motion to proceed with a model, though the board is not required to use the model the district recommends.

“It’s important to note that in this process, we have shared so much data, we have gathered input from stakeholders, we have the restructuring committee,” Board Chair Aubrey Nichols said. “During that time, our district has not given its recommendation. However, our district staff are the ones who will be implementing whatever the board chooses, and their recommendation is important to me. So I look forward to hearing that.”

The Nov. 17 meeting follows more than two months of committees, work sessions, and parent listening sessions as the district weighs closing up to two schools to restore four furlough days, redistribute class sizes, and increase the number of teachers per grade level in elementary schools. It is not guaranteed that the board will select a model or move forward with restructuring after the Nov. 17 board meeting.

Before the Nov. 9 work session, all seven board members filled out a ranking sheet of five proposed school-closure models: Models C, D, G, H, and J. All models except Model J propose closing at least Ewing Young Elementary and one other school. Model J, a new model that was not presented to the District Restructuring Committee, proposes closing Crater Elementary and Joan Austin Elementary.

The exterior of Antonia Crater Elementary in north Newberg, Ore. on Nov. 16, 2026. (Branden Andersen / Newsberg)
The exterior of Antonia Crater Elementary in north Newberg, Ore. on Nov. 16, 2026. (Branden Andersen / Newsberg)

The board reviewed each member’s ranking of all the models at the meeting, and members shared the thought processes and emphases behind their choices. The members ranked each model through nine lenses: budget, capacity, student impact, class-size distribution, facilities and closed buildings, community impact and equity, transportation and access, enrollment trends, and implementation and transition.

“We asked [board members] for each lens on every model to go through and rank, write the pros and the cons for each of those models in that lens, and then rank one through five, five being the best of the five models and one being the weakest of the five models,” Superintendent Dave Parker said.

Models C, D, G, and H would clear the $1 million threshold for restoring the four furlough days and would increase the teacher-per-grade-level ratio. Model J was removed from consideration as it would not save the district $1 million and would have the worst class-size spread, according to Parker’s presentation at the meeting.

According to the rankings reviewed at the meeting, board members were aligned on several areas, such as five or more members agreeing that Model D best addresses the district’s needs in the categories of student impact and implementation and transition, while Model H best addresses the budget category. They diverged on enrollment, where three members thought Model C was more effective and the other four were split among Models D, G, and J.

For the remaining categories other than capacity, budget, and enrollment, four of the seven board members chose Model D as the highest-ranked model. Members leaned toward Model C in the capacity category, with four members ranking it above other models.

The board members offered opinions on how closures could affect different community members, from economic effects to geographic distance, and discussed the benefits and drawbacks of each of the five models during the three-hour meeting.

“I understand the amount of care and consideration that has gone into this,” Nichols said. “I know that I speak for the board when I say this is not something we are taking lightly. This is something we are all deeply invested in, and deeply invested in making the choices that are best for our whole district.”

Ewing Young Elementary on May 24, 2026. (Branden Andersen / Newsberg)
Ewing Young Elementary on May 24, 2026. (Branden Andersen / Newsberg)

Vice Chair Andy Byerley said the choice the board makes Nov. 17 will have implications for families in the district.

“There are real humans behind this process and behind this data, and that makes it more than an answer to a math problem,” Byerley said. “There are real implications to communities here, students, staff, families, alumni. And I have such compassion for those listening tonight who already feel a sense of grief at the potential loss of community.”